Could I be the "his" exception?

21 posts / 0 new
Last post
#1 Mar 13 - 7PM
beamoflight
beamoflight's picture

Could I be the "his" exception?

I have a question for everybody. I have hunted and hunted for an answer.

I emailed Lisa this week and the angel that she is got back to me and explained that my WHWTMAIHNIA (whatever-he-was-to-me-as-I-Have-no-idea-anymore) Guy does indeed fit the profile as a narcissist. I thought he would.

Ok, this is what I know & have done--
(1) I know he's a narcissist
(2) I know he has done/said some unbelievable and hurtful stuff to me
(3) I know he is dating another woman (well, pretty sure of it anyway)
(4) I know we have had NC for 1 month to the day
(5) I have tried in vain to get him to see the other side of how he can make people feel
(6) I have explained to him how his behavior will affect his children

KNOWING AND DOING ALL OF THE ABOVE---

CAN SOMEBODY PLEASE TELL ME WHY I FEEL SO COMPELLED TO LET THIS MEAN & EVIL MAN KNOW--

THAT IF HE NEEDS A FRIEND I AM HERE FOR HIM AND THAT EVEN THOUGH HE MAY THINK NOBODY REALLY CARES-- I DO & ALWAYS WILL.

Please, I am 1 month NC, and everyday I feel like I abandoned him. I feel like absolute idiot sending anything to him (even via email).

BUT, whenever I did really need him, he was there for me-- as long as I didn't push my emotions on him.

like, when I was getting sued, he was there for me 1000% no questions asked, but when my son was in the hospital he ran away & said he could not handle being around sick children... BUT when the banks were bullying me he sued them too?!?!?!? At practically no cost to me-- even laid out the money.

I know, I KNOW he's a narcissist-- I know this, I know he's an @$$hole at times-- but, why do I feel like I am his exception? I sometimes feel like I (my monthy emails that is-- I cut off any visits & phone calls a while ago as, whew! he was bad sometimes) kept him grounded. Does that make sense?

Please, somebody? can it be explained why I feel like this? Is it in my head?

I always took the time after he said/did something VERY hurtful to explain to him exactly what and how I was feeling. It was almost alien to him & I could tell, he needed that. I knew he was "learning" from me-- I could feel it, the problem is he would usally get worse & run away right after. Like he had to punish me & him for letting his guard down.

I'm sorry for such a long post but I really feel so-- I dont know what I feel anymore. I just don't know.

It's not about dating him or a relationship as I know he's dating other women, I know it-- I just feel like I was his only (or one of his only) real friends.

Mar 14 - 5PM
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

Oh gosh this breaks my heart

Oh gosh this breaks my heart to read. Reminds me so much of myself when he first abandon me. I was looking for any validation. I mean any. I remember he in fact told me I was an exception. "I would never get involved with a married woman but you have always been an exception" Lie Lie Lie. Yes I do believe they have their favorites but its not like you think. Its not good to be a favorite. Im sorry sweets. I know it hurts so bad. This is the getting real part
Mar 14 - 2PM
Steph
Steph's picture

I used to think that too. Now

I used to think that too. Now I think that the woman before me and the women after me, probably all felt or feel like the "exception" too. So, short answer. No. I don't think any woman is an exception or more special to them. Everything is "in the moment" for them. It's sad, but I don't think they really value anyone they are with:(
Mar 14 - 6AM
IncognitoBurrito
IncognitoBurrito's picture

BeamofLight

Your post rips my heart out. Sounds like all of the thoughts that swirl around in my head, lately. I know I'm still experiencing cognitive dissonance, and some measure of denial. I'd like very much to believe that I'm an exception. He made me feel like one. I'm not, I've been little more than- as Agnes so aptly describes- a rat, pressing a lever. However, if that's the absolute BEST he can do, then it ISN'T ENOUGH FOR ME! It's simply not enough. I expect, require and demand more. I accept NOTHING less, than what I have to GIVE back, in a relationship. I have all the space in the world, in my heart, for friends- but he doesn't even meet THE BASIC CRITERIA for as much! My friends don't headf*ck me. My friends check on me, and show a general interest in what I'm up to, and how I've been. My friends don't leave me second-guessing decisions I've made in my life, in order to assert themselves into it. My friends don't send me sexy photos of themselves. My friends don't put these dream-like scenarios of our imaginary future together, in my head. My friends don't try to test the waters with me, to see if they can romance me, to feel better about themselves. I don't find myself making excuses for my friends, because they can explain THEMSELVES, when necessary. My friends don't run hot and cold. I have even-keeled, level-headed friends, and people, in my life. I require that, as it keeps ME SANE! I know what to expect, I can count on them. I didn't have this growing up, and I require it now, as an adult. He can have his rollercoaster of emotions, and crazy-making illusions. I can dream these things up alone, all by myself. In much bigger, and brighter detail, I might add! I'm unpredictable enough, as it is. I require the waking facts, and stability, in order to thrive. I hope that's helpful?
Mar 14 - 5AM
dazed and seeki...
dazed and seeking peace and strength's picture

beamoflight

this is exactly how i feel. i am still very much in the midst of getting out, so i'm definitely not as experienced or as wise as some of the other women here. but one thing that i read somewhere stuck with me a lot: does somebody who constantly hurts you, also constantly makes you feel bad for him? my answer: a resounding YES! my N had some good qualities and i kept thinking he was really good deep down, just unrefined due to a traumatic childhood. i felt like i was his only friend (Ns don't have friends) and he always made me feel like i was his only friend bc in reality, he did have a hard time making and keeping friends. and i loved him so i felt like i would never abandon him. even now when i think about it, i feel sad for him and it pulls at my heart strings. i am learning not to confuse with pity and heart-strings-tugging with genuine love. he made me feel bad for him a lot, and i did. when i started learning about PDs, i was really enlightened to the fact that all of this - the good *and* the bad is part of it. so it's not that the PD is his bad side, but there is a good side that isn't a part of the PD. this made me more aware of the good things and really reflect on why he was good sometimes. i started to really question the patterns of "good behavior" and i became really skeptical. he was there when it wasn't difficult for him. but if it was too much for him - no matter how much i needed him - he couldn't be there. once again, what he gave revolved around him, his convenience, his resources. that isn't really "giving" is it? i don't know what to say - it's sad to feel like we are abandoning them (and i agree, it's not even about a "relationship" here), but we don't want to say "i'm not your friend" bc it seems so mean and cold. and we loved them so it's hard not to feel like this. i guess i'm just confirming your feelings. but i know for me, his "good deeds" seem less benevolent and genuine after learning more and seeing patterns. perhaps it would be worth taking time to ask why he was so good to you at some points and not at others. you might discover a pattern and explanation... good luck to you! HUGS.
Mar 14 - 5PM (Reply to #17)
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

Dont feel too bad for them

Dont feel too bad for them ladies, I promise you there will be someone right there to take your place and they will tell them all the same stuff they told you. Its really hard to grasp and it hurts terribly but it is the 100% the truth. Eventually the goal is for you to move beyond focusing on his illness and begin to focus on what in you would crave to be with someone who clearly mistreats you. There's something behind it because most people wouldnt except the behvior they dish out to us let alone ask for more of it. We have a role is this little dynamic and everyones is different. For me its my codependence and the trauma bond for ya'll it may be something else but look for it, I promise you its there. Once you find it is when the healing begins. I spent months on here trying to find out what got me here. I came from a very "nice" family where there was absoulutely no abuse present but I came to realize there were some dynamics with my parents that I believe contributed to this it wasnt just them but the narc too (when I was much younger) that made this dynamic familiar and comfortable to me. I know you think "sick of it this is not comfortable for me but you will see in time that you did find some sort of comfort in it or you wouldnt have continued to put up with. All Im saying is investigate how you got here
Mar 14 - 2AM
Bitter-sweet
Bitter-sweet's picture

Dealing with loss

I agree with Ewa, eventually you come around to believing that the special connection you felt was just in you- and most likely, not returned. I struggled like you but I also had to look inside and acknowledge that I am not good at dealing with loss. I realise that when I attach to someone, I do so very strongly and then it's hard to let go mentallly if things go wrong. That's something I need to work on... It was hard with the N because I knew him first when I was just a girl and he came looking for me 25 years later. Letting go of him this time, I felt like I was letting go of my past too- the time when I was young and hopeful. Perhaps it's hard to detach because we are not just letting go of them but a lot of other stuff- our dreams, hopes, desire to be wanted etc and it feels frightening to lose someone we felt strongly about and maybe admit we made a mistake. Your N has sometimes been there for you and sometimes not. I suspect most Ns are not reliable, we deserve more.
Mar 14 - 2AM
agnesmurphy17
agnesmurphy17's picture

Intermittent Reinforcement

STAGE 1: Running hot & cold is called intermittent reinforcement. If a rat is in a cage and pushes a lever, he gets food every time. (The honeymoon phase with N when everything is perfect, better than with any other man because all your wishes for instant gratification are satisfied.) SCENARIO A: Then the lever is reprogramed to work intermittently, sometimes a push works & sometimes not. (The N starts the devaluing & even discarding. But he always comes back. And sometimes he does wonderful & generous acts.) In this situation the rat will forever press the lever in the hopes that this time there will be food. (A woman is not a rat & she should see dude is a rat & this will be her live with Dr. J & Mr. H.) SCENARIO B: However, if after always pressing the lever in Stage 1, the lever is reprogramed to never give food when pressed--the rat will soon never press the lever again. (If the N is always a nasty bully, the victim might take off. Unless she was pre-programmed in her family of origin to knock her head against the wall.) SCENARIO C: If the lever is reprogramed to Scenario A -- work intermittently -- then again reprogramed to Scenario B -- never to work -- nevertheless, the rat will, in the beginning press the lever frequently. Then the rat will press less & less. However, every once and awhile the rat will go over & press just on the off chance there is food. So, there you have it. What works for rats works for people. But, we are not rats. Don't be fooled. Go find your own way to happiness. Do not hang around for random reinforcement from your N.
Mar 14 - 6AM (Reply to #14)
beamoflight
beamoflight's picture

wow, that was clear! wow,

wow, that was clear! wow, clear. I think... I am going to print & cut that out and read it everytime I feel myself fall. Thanks.
Mar 14 - 5AM (Reply to #13)
ewa
ewa's picture

Yes, this is unfortunately

Yes, this is unfortunately happened to us, we have been programmed, and this is I suppose, because of our low self-esteem. I like this example with rats, it describes the process good. They have programmed us, for us to believe there is good things in them , and that they are warm, loving humans..in fact there is nothing just a skeleton with some meat on it with no soul, with no real feelings. This is hard to believe so in the first step we need to accept it. If we cannot understand something , and we cannot change something the best is to accept it. Looking for the answers doesn’t help, it just prolong our pain. I think this acceptance is the most important step to our recovery. We will never get closer and this is what we need to accept too.
Mar 14 - 1AM
ewa
ewa's picture

Well, i am really sorry to

Well, i am really sorry to say it to you but i could see the situation with my N as you see it now. Mine was there for me when i was looking for the flat, he was there for me when i was taking my driving exam and he even took the day of to take me to the driving school, before the exam he allowed me to drive his expensive car, i crashed it a bit and that was not a big deal for him. Yes ...in some situtations he was there for me, especially if it was about imporving my skills driving, skiing etc.. But otherwise he treated me badly, he knew i will forgive everything..On the begining i have even forgiven him his cheating. With time he will be there for you less and less. You (sorry for assumption) love him..and he is dating other woman..how can you be his friend in this case? Anyway no friendship with N is possible. I know how you feel i had this thoughts and feelings before. Me myself i still feel a speciall connection to my exN, but i went to conclusion this special connection is only in my head..he moved on and is planning his wedding with a new supply he knows shortly. Hugs.
Mar 13 - 10PM
michele115 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Beamoflight

Everything you have expressed, virtually *there may be an exception* everyone on this board has struggled with...you are not alone and I fear, to the narc...you were not unique. What you are wondering is normal, this is a very hard reality to grasp...and once you grasp it...hard to accept. I feel like a broken record here...BUT having some time under my belt and still very much IN the process... I will use an analogy that at least for me was helpful... I really don't know who has the rights to this gem but it is as clear and black and white as you can get with understanding this... If we want to talk about being the exception...the best way that it can be described is being the exception say amongst a group of toasters? Some of the other people in his life might very well be the cheap low quality type you find at the local convenience store...I don't know where you're from but let's say a CVS, Walgreens or a Rite Aid? Then you have your middle models...those would be in Target or Walmart...maybe even a K-mart Then you have the upper echelon models...guess say The Sharper Image or perhaps "Macy's Cellar" And they have the same comparison of feelings towards us that say normal people would have to such toasters. That is pretty much it in a nutshell... They use people for as long as they are useful...that is it. Anything they do in kind is tied to a personal gain on their part. So when they are kind and giving...it is so that they will be looked upon as kind, nice, generous people...which of course works so well when you are no longer useful and they turn on you leaving you wondering just what the heck happened because they were soooo "nice" leaving you in sheer disbelief. Are they happy? Do they like doing this? I doubt it...but it is the nature of the beast. You as a normal person in the eyes, heart and mind of a Narc at best are the exception of say being a Sharper Image toaster as opposed to being from CVS. Me personally, I want to be considered a warm body with feelings...not a piece of metal that serves a function. I wish you well with your journey...it is not an easy one and we probably very well will have many more conversations where I'm reminding you about the toaster. This is not to discredit or undermine your ability to understand...it's just a part of this damn process. I can promise you however, that with some time under your belt, once you can break away and as time passes, the fog lifts some...the second guessing, wondering, and cycling towards empathy...somehow hoping there is a loophole somewhere where the "narc" is special enough to see...been there...made efforts too...their behavior is textbook. Is there an area where there might be hope...well I don't want to be a pessimist but the REALITY today as we know it is that even the professionals wash their hands. Whether this is moral or not is not really the issue. The goal here is to get out of crisis and save ourselves because the reality is the Narcs could care less and in many cases, before the sheets have cooled are already on to their next source of supply...which we can refer to as "toasters." Certainly, I will extend you the courtesy of deciding the quality of the current "merchandise" a.k.a. newest supply but it is as cold and detached as that. Very sorry we have to meet under these circumstances...but I do look forward to communicating with you further and helping you along as best I can. That being said, I can promise if you do the work and stay committed to recovering...this will pass and you will feel better. Hugs!
Mar 14 - 5PM (Reply to #10)
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

I would venture to say that

I would venture to say that while they love Neiman's model they find them too much up keep and then they begin to shop at walmart for even more of a disposable model
Mar 14 - 1PM (Reply to #8)
ifinallygotit
ifinallygotit's picture

michele115

Thank you for sharing your wisdom. This really helped me detach from feeling so abandoned today - I think I was a high quality but used toaster...getting old.
Mar 14 - 1PM (Reply to #9)
michele115 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Ifinallygotit...

Well that should work wonders for your self esteem...as I sit here trying to undo the wreckage as I fear in my description - perhaps out of shame...I failed to share that I wasn't even able to make it to the CVS category...I was a "used" toaster from the Goodwill...LMAO!
Mar 14 - 6AM (Reply to #7)
beamoflight
beamoflight's picture

Thank you. CVS, Target,

Thank you. CVS, Target, Macys-- sadly, I wonder... I think you are right. He told me once that he can only be with pretty women who are good in bed. BING! BA-BING, BING, BING!!!!
Mar 13 - 10PM
ifinallygotit
ifinallygotit's picture

the mind f**K

No, you are not crazy, he is. This is why we are all in such a daze trying to catch ourselves. They were not all bad or we would not have hung in there...Mine was the same, my rock for many things that did not involve emotionally giving and committing...Mine even did all my laundry for me for 1.5 years; it would come back folded pefectly! This was during a time when my work was very busy and really needed some help. I also KNEW I was his only real friend even though he is more popular and had more friends than anyone I have ever seen. I would often ask him about his odd behavior and try to help him understand the impact on me... We were good friends to them and they gave back in their own limited way. We wanted to believe they were not that bad. But there is no bonding or loyalty...we can be replaced in a moment. They are not suffering a loss like we are. They are watching TV and getting laid by new women. They are not mourning the loss of their lover and closest friend. It is all too freaky...they are just not normal guys - but mine had a sweet, quiet nature when not busy pushing me away and destroying us. We project our own feelings on to them because we are normal and assume they are too - not.
Mar 13 - 10PM (Reply to #2)
beamoflight
beamoflight's picture

We were good friends to them

We were good friends to them and they gave back in their own limited way. **I wonder-- did he do this with every woman he met??? It is a total mind f%ck. We wanted to believe they were not that bad. **This is 100% how I feel. He's not all bad-- deep in him is a soul. But there is no bonding or loyalty...we can be replaced in a moment. **You think? I often wonder if mine thinks of me. They are not suffering a loss like we are. They are watching TV and getting laid by new women. **Well, here I agree with you (not that I haven't already) They are not mourning the loss of their lover and closest friend. **Wow, I hope you're wrong but sadly I think you're right. It is all too freaky...they are just not normal guys - but mine had a sweet, quiet nature when not busy pushing me away and destroying us. **Mine too. We project our own feelings on to them because we are normal and assume they are too - not. HE IS MENTALLY ILL-- I've started saying this to myself before bed at night. I'll let you know how it's working out.
Mar 14 - 1AM (Reply to #3)
It'sAllAboutMeNow (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Mentally ill VS. the Mentally screwed

It's a quarter till 3 a.m. and I'm awake because my mind won't quiet enough to let me rest. Today was my day to wonder the same thing... could he be an exception to the rule of Narcs? The guy cheated on me and that in my book is unforgivable. At this point I just WANT to believe that he really did care. Throughout our relationship he was only nasty if I quetioned his behavior. He was otherwise sweet, affectionate, and we had a ton of fun together. I had the opportunity to speak with one of his exes with whom he was sleeping with behind my back. He had lied to her (surprise, surprise) about being in a relatioship, which doesn't surpise me in the least bit. We of course exchanged stories about our experiences with him and he was very different with me and the reltionship was longer. I know there was something that kept him drawn to me but not in a human way. Sometimes I wondered if it was my desire and effort to grow as person through therapy and other outlets. I could tell he knew he was broken. It's very clear to me that I was just an object to him otherwise why cheat, lie, and decieve me?!?! I walked away from the relationship after discovering he was cheatng leaving him blind sided because things had been going well or at least that's the picture he had painted. It's so easy to fantasize about him missing me and feeling bad for what he's done. I guess at the end of the day if thinking that he does, gives me some sort of comfort then it doesn't matter whether he really is because I know there's no going back. The best way I have been able to digest these ideas is to just accept the nice times we had but to NEVER let myself forget who he truely is! He'll always be the mentally ill guy who mentally screwed me. So I say; no thanks, close the tab please, seal that door shut, nail that coffin, and shows over every time I start to miss the illusion that was him. I wish you the a speady road to recovery from this but michelle speaks truth when she says it's about time. I've learned to make a visit here before my mind gets the best of me. =)
Mar 14 - 6AM (Reply to #4)
beamoflight
beamoflight's picture

Reading this-- I look back

Reading this-- I look back now and think that-- (a) I WAS special because I would do things sexually that most women would not. (I told my GF's some of the things we did-- that I enjoyed and they were like "hell no!") (b) I WAS NO LONGER special because I would not tolerate his bad behavior and questioned him on it-- thus causing the whole hot/cold thing (c) I THINK if he could he would take his fashion model GF's looks and my attitude toward sex and gel us into the "perfect woman". (d) I THINK that I represent the "family" half of life and she represents the exciting part of life-- and he wants both and I would not be a 1/2 woman. (e) I THINK that he will never be happy and even if one day he marries the GF-- he can't escape that I could be both-- HE just would never let me. I think that HE is very toxic.
Mar 14 - 12PM (Reply to #5)
JMi
JMi's picture

After reading this i am

After reading this i am pretty much convinced there is such a thing as 'brother from another mother' Although it might have to be distant relatives as i live in UK!!! Beam we were dating twins - you said my story echoed yours, well this echoes too! Scarily!