why does he come back?

24 posts / 0 new
Last post
#1 Feb 21 - 10PM
dazed and seeki...
dazed and seeking peace and strength's picture

why does he come back?

I'm new here, but I've been reading your posts for the last couple of months. I went through a terrible time with my exbf (who I'm pretty sure is a Narc). What I wanted to ask you guys is this:

Why does he continue to come back?

I'm on day 7 of no contact. We have dated for 2.5 years. I found out he cheated on me back in November. Since then, it has been an incredibly painful journey. Other than the cheating, our relationship reeks of a relationship with a narc/sociopath. I only realized this after speaking to my therapist.

Anyway, to avoid the long story...the last I heard from him was this:

"you b*tch you c*nt, I don't care if you die as long as it doesn't happen under my watch" (this was after I said I felt like killing myself because I was in so much pain). He then proceeded to call his mother who called me to "calm" me down. Even though I had already made it clear to him that in fact, I wasn't intending on doing such a thing. I just wanted him to give me some breathing space. He wrote me to tell me to never contact him ever again. And he left me hanging to deal with my pain. I reached out here and there since and only got burned each time but verbal abuse. And now I finally successfully did 1 week of NC, and he has been texting and writing me in the last few days. This last email came this morning and said: and

"I really miss you and I wanted to talk to you. I don't have your phone number, I don't know if your getting my emails, it's hard to know if you are just ignoring me or if you're not getting my emails. I would appreciate it if you would let me know "yes or no" if you'll talk. Take care,"

I changed my number shortly after this incident. I've been just reading up a lot on these types of relationships. I know my description is a bit vague and crazy, but trust me, I will just be describing what you all have been describing in your relationships.

What I don't understand is: after treating me like that and ending like that WHY is he contacting me? He lives in another country. He has had a strong hold on me for a long time now. He even spent a lot of money and flew me to see him for a week in January.

What could he possibly want from me now? He can get women in the country he is living in now - he found 2 alreayd during our relationship.

I don't get it! And I have had the HARDEST time breaking from this relationship. I was insanely in love with him - sometimes I feel like I still am. It has been really painful. I wish he would stop with the swinging back and forth and honestly I cannot come up with a reason for coming back. I keep wondering if maybe he is NOT a narc and really does love me...but the signs are all there.

Any thoughts? I understand this whole "Narc Suppy" thing - but honestly, I have not been a good source of supple bc I am always mad and always telling him what he is doing wrong. So this kind of goes against the books no?

Sorry for the super long post. I normally don't do this, but I am in a bind as to whether to response. Of course it's tempting. But I am scared of being burned even worse.

And on a another note, thank you to all of your for posting and being such a strong voice. It has gotten people like me through these really dark times. I have felt alone until I stumbled upon this site - mostly because you all seem to know what I am going through. So thank you. You all are incredible and inspiring.

Feb 22 - 11AM
dazed and seeki...
dazed and seeking peace and strength's picture

More questions and still in disbelief!

I am sorry for all of the questions. I'd like the chance to respond to everybody - you all have been immensely helpful. He is all of a sudden trying to reach out to me full force. He texted me on my google voice number (which I have no yet changed) and left two voice messages on it. His text: Are you there? His voicemails: essentially saying he just wants to know how I'm doing, he misses me, and I was such a big part of his life that the fact that I am not there is making him uneasy. I understand what everybody is saying. No contact is getting hard as he pursues this. I was doing fine when he wasn't reaching out. Now I constantly feel the urge to respond. Why? Because I have so much to say to him. I cannot believe how he left me hanging and the MANNER in which he did was completely crude and cruel. I want to give him a piece of my mind... Does this ever provide closure to be able to say these things? Or does it usually back fire? I mean I have never really sought closure, so this would be the first time. I know somebody said there is no need to even want to respond. Just close. But this is eating at me. Have you ever found it worth it to respond and to say something to him? It's as if all of the horrendous things that have happened never did - I am seeing a therapist now, and that is a big deal. It's really frustrating to feel like he doesn't get it...and that he won't get it even if I tried to explain to him. Are there ANY pros to responding to him? I'm sorry if I'm just venting. I just cannot believe he is now trying to talk to me and is trying to get back in communication full force after all that has happened....
Feb 22 - 1PM (Reply to #23)
Journey
Journey's picture

It is so confusing when WE try to relate...

Dazed, these are your words: "you b*tch you c*nt, I don't care if you die as long as it doesn't happen under my watch" (this was after I said I felt like killing myself because I was in so much pain). He then proceeded to call his mother who called me to "calm" me down. Even though I had already made it clear to him that in fact, I wasn't intending on doing such a thing. I just wanted him to give me some breathing space. He wrote me to tell me to never contact him ever again. And he left me hanging to deal with my pain. I reached out here and there since and only got burned each time but verbal abuse." THIS is his last way of relating to you until YOU decided to stay away. It is illogical to say the least that he feels any different now under the surface of the mask he is presenting in his desperation to gain control again. Do what you need to do and if that means contacting him then you know we will still be here for you, but remember the pain he's caused you... Closure will likely never be what you hope it will be with him. Going back often makes them treat us even worse because it tells them you'll accept it from him and still be there - for HIM. It really is all about him. He isn't capable of caring about you and has proved it time and again from what you've told us. Trust yourself now. Like others have said, we sometimes need the proof by going back and you may need that. Stay close to us here regardless, don't feel shame if you do. We all understand only too well the pain and confusion you are feeling. Journey on...

Journey on...

Feb 22 - 12PM (Reply to #22)
Disillusionedx2
Disillusionedx2's picture

You seem to want to test the fire.....

No matter what anyone says you're going to do what you feel, as the ladies have all stated, is truth, tell him off, say what you want, if you feel it's closure to you then maybe it is, don't expect the response you want, they are unpredictable and hate to be to be "told off" they will turn it around as you know he does and it will surely back fire, you won't learn until you touch the fire, I would encourage deleting all of his text, messages and change all contact information, they DO NOT CHANGE, behavoir will only get worse, so long as he can suck you in and you let him, it's supply for him to keep the cycle going, YOU'RE IN CONTROL NOW, you call the shot's, it doesn't matter what he wants, it's no longer about him, think about yourself, they don't want to hear the truth, their entire life is based on a lie, an illusion, truth plays a very small part in the Narc drama, don't do it....

stay~strong

Feb 22 - 11AM (Reply to #21)
ally2375
ally2375's picture

Dazed

Perhaps the hardest part of getting over a relationship with a PDI is the lack of closure. After all, when you're involved with a NON-disordered person and the relationship doesn't work out, there's usually a break up...you know an actual BREAK. That's the thing with these guys. They rarely end it with you permanently. They may say it's over, disappear for awhile, but it doesn't last most of the time. He NEEDS the validation that comes with knowing that you still want him and that he still has some control over you. If you respond in any way, it confirms this for him and he is assuaged. That's why they tend to disappear when we rise to the bait - our response (ANY response) was all they ever wanted. Think of it as leaving an animal for dead, walking away, and then coming back to give it one final kick to make sure it's REALLY dead. Are there any pros to responding to him? It depends on what you're looking for. If you want from him closure, understanding, or empathy, you're on a dead end road. He CAN'T give this to you. If you need further proof that he's a user who doesn't care about anyone but himself, then yes. This he can give you, probably in short order. It's totally your choice. We're trying to spare you the pain that we know will follow if you contact him. Some lessons have to be learned the hard way though. Good luck! Hugs, Ally
Feb 22 - 11AM (Reply to #20)
Hunter
Hunter's picture

Dazed

Delete,Delete,Delete! My guess is you won't listen, so I suggest you respond! What will he do? He devalue you, remember it's all about him! It's all your fault. These are choices you need to make. When you have enough you will no longer contact him. You can stay stuck or you can Go NC and begin to heal! Personally I think it should be all about you! Good Luck Idealk
Feb 22 - 9AM
Hunter
Hunter's picture

Dazed

Hi You get it, you need to follow through with NC! Why is he doing this? Well... He's nuts and making you nuts in the process. I'm sorry you get to be a part of our group, welcome! The bottom line is this now needs to be about you. In order for you regain who you are NC is the drug of choice. Get ready for the ride of your life. As I always say you have to start at the beginig to get to the end. Be glad you found us, we will help you survive. Get a calendar and mark off NCdays that pass. Write a pros and con list in regards to this relationship! Guess which list will be linger? Yep,cons. Keep busy and fight! If you follow the rules you will win this battle! I promise. You also need to learn, this man has a disorder, trying to figure it out won't work, he is cancer with no cure! Good Luck Idealk
Feb 22 - 8AM
really
really's picture

He comes back because you let

He comes back because you let him. It will go on like this forever, each time getting worse and harder, if you let it. You said, "But I am scared of being burned even worse." If that is true, leave it alone and do not respond.
Feb 22 - 6AM
Mariline
Mariline's picture

He comes back because to him

He comes back because to him it is just a matter of power. No love. Just power. Or better, control. They have no feelings. No pride, no remorse. It means nothing to him to apologize, it is simply a way to get control over you again. That's all that matters: control. Do not think that control is love. It is just the opposite. gain your dignity back. The more NC, the more dignity you get. The more NC, the more healing. He cannot stand this.
Feb 22 - 5AM
Disillusionedx2
Disillusionedx2's picture

welcome aboard

I know that you have read a great deal about NPD, toxic, dysfunctional relationships with an N/P, keep reading as it takes a while for it to sink in. It's unbelievable there are people out in the world that behave in this manner and what's worse is, we happened upon them or they us! Yes, you have heard it all, read it, and it's true, control/supply is their food source, they need, and feed from it every waking moment of their lives, they feel entitled to any/everything no matter if they deserve it or not, even if they didn't work for it. They seriously think they are so special that you will end your life over them. N told me he was speaking with a former gf as she was suicidal because he would not be with her, he also insinuated to me I was suicidal, I stopped him in his tracks, told him, yes, I feel horrible but please believe I would never take my own life over you nor anyone else for that matter, puhlease...spoke with Xgf and we laughed, she was furious about him saying she was suicidal, she was not and never have been, they're sick! How dare you change your number, they hate indifference and being ignored, the changing of your number infuriates him, he's going to punish you if/when you break NC, this time will feel worse as you already know who/what he is, no doubt about it, but it's like playing with fire, knowing it's hot and will burn you, that's what will happen. I went in for several rounds but the beginning it was not obvious I was being pulled back and forth, so the major lure I went back in and bam, back down I went, it's like he saved up everything he perceived I did to hurt him and went for the jugular, it was awful, I was making great progress too, back to NC 5 months now and although he has hovered, I will never go back for another round, even if my life depended upon it. It can turn into an addiction for you also, you will miss the madness because that's all you have been used to, him...just being a narc, that's what he will continue to do, with you if you allow him with whomever else he is involved with, N here had his mom call me on several occasions to "patch" things up, disgusting, what adult does that? Do not go back in, detox from him, it won't be easy, it may be a very dark time, and you may want to go back just to get from under that cloud but don't do it, the storm will pass, the clouds will lift, your days will become brighter, give yourself time to process the emotions, seek counseling if you have to, and continue to educate yourself, knowledge will be your power, and since you feel comfy with the board, stay close, your plight is totally understood, you won't be judged, everyone here has been in your shoes, best wishes Hun!

stay~strong

Feb 22 - 5AM
agnesmurphy17
agnesmurphy17's picture

The Question Is?

The question is why do you let him come back? Why do you even listen? Give up the hope that he's ever gonna change. There is somebody or something in your past which makes you susceptible to this man. Something familiar in this running hot & cold. It's complicated & not obvious . . . but it's there.
Feb 22 - 3AM
Journey
Journey's picture

Welcome Dazed

All the members here that have posted so far are right on. The way you feel now is exactly why we are all here. The confusion, the mixed messages, the push pull... are all indicators of being in a relationship with a narc or cluster B personality. You will need to read more about what these mean to know where your ex fits into it, but just from what you have said I have no doubt he does. You said in a post below "Every time I want to reach out to him - I pull back remembering how he normally responds." Remember that! If he responds differently it is only because he wants to be in control - but since there is a 'normal' way he responds, if he is unnaturally nice and loving something must be up and as heart breaking as it is, what HE says it is, is a lie. These guys don't change their behavior on a deeper level, only on the surface when he puts the mask back on. He was horribly abusive and cruel to you the last time you heard from him before this most recent email. He told you he didn't care if you were dead. Now he's all of a sudden acting like that previous conversation didn't even happen?! That he misses you? Wondering why he can't get a hold of you? WTF! THAT screams disorder! He is just panicking because of the loss of control and power over you - what he said in his email sounds desperate and it is, because you are slipping away from his grasp. Sorry to be so blunt, but that's all he cares about. Not you, not really :( Stay with us here, read all the articles... learn as much as you can. Awakening is a slap in the face, but it doesn't sting as much as his continued abuse will keep hurting you if you believe he cares, only to find out over and over his actions don't prove it and verbal and emotional abuse is what you end up with for giving your kind heart and trusting love to him. Be strong, stay away. ((hugs))

Journey on...

Feb 21 - 11PM
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

Im gonna give you the short

Im gonna give you the short answer since Im on my way to bed. Its because he can. Sorry you have to be on this board but Welcome atleast you are not alone
Feb 21 - 11PM (Reply to #12)
dazed and seeki...
dazed and seeking peace and strength's picture

Haha, that should stop me

Haha, that should stop me from contacting him. That short statement carries so much truth... I will have to kill the part of me that secretly wants him to continue coming back.
Feb 21 - 11PM
justicejones
justicejones's picture

I hope you get your peace...

With these type of personality disordered types, it's all about control. He wants to know that he still has a hold on you...that you can't go on without him. They live off of the need that you need them in your life to "survive"...which you don't. It is an extreme ego boost to be "needed" by you. The whole world revolves around them and is because of them in their mind. It makes them crazy if you are moving on and don't need them, because then they feel like they have lost control and their narcissistic source. A lot of the "victims" of these Narcs find it flattering in the early stages that the Narc keeps coming back. But remember, it's not cause they have changed or even are sorry. It is to ensure you are right where they want you....
Feb 21 - 11PM (Reply to #8)
dazed and seeki...
dazed and seeking peace and strength's picture

@justicejones - thank you

Thank you for your response. This actually helped because it made sense. I forgot about the "control" factor. I am still struggling to understand narcissism at full length, and I feel like I am juggling quite a bit of information in my head - along with the trauma of having just gone through a terrible relationship. I am sure he wants to exert control because he sure wasn't there for me when I reached out to him and expressed the immense pain I was in. He left me alone to deal with it on my own - no explanations, no sympathy, no compassion. And this is a man who claimed to have loved me and wanted to marry me. So I assume it does no good to respond to him. It's just still mind-boggling to know that I fell in love with a man with whom I cannot have an adult conversation to sort these things out. Every time I want to reach out to him - I pull back remembering how he normally responds. It's quite absurd, and I'm still in a daze as to what happened these past few years. :( Again, thank you.
Feb 22 - 7AM (Reply to #9)
Disillusionedx2
Disillusionedx2's picture

forget about closure

Except to close your heart to him, he doesn't deserve it, and the short story is they are FAKE, FALSE, WALKING, TALKING LYING, CONTRADICTIONS, nope, no love in that cold empty, souless alien, just reacting what he has "learned" to say/do, they are NEVER there in time of your need, no matter what it is, they will find a way to back out and blame you for them not being away, "you pushed me away" "you made me call you those ugly names" "you did this" "you said that" blah blah blah, weak links, they are EMPTY through and through, don't look back, he won't be there....just an illusion.

stay~strong

Feb 22 - 9AM (Reply to #10)
Disillusionedx2
Disillusionedx2's picture

I'd also like to add

Do not be the least bit surprised if/when you do respond, he will go mute, oh yea, great at those games, I didn't realize it early on but eventually I came to learn about his behavior, he would call or text me, if I didn't answer my phone right away or answer the text in a timely manner he would completely ignore me when I did return the call/text, for the longest I thought we were playing phone tag/txt ya know? lol, nope, it was him being the N that he is, sick, I can't stand them, when you reach the point of indifference, become angry, it will become clearer to you, until then maintain the NC so you can C your way out! _./'..._¸¸.•¤**¤•.¸.•¤**¤•..•¤ **¤ •.¸.•¤**¤•.. *•. .•* *!!!.. Best~Wishes /.•*•... ¸..•¤**¤•.,.•¤**¤•.*.•¤**¤•.¸ .•¤ **¤•

stay~strong

Feb 21 - 11PM (Reply to #2)
justicejones
justicejones's picture

PS...

Though you feel like you haven't been a good source for him, it doesn't matter. You were a source of supply and the more they have scattered around in case the others dry up, the better for them.
Feb 21 - 11PM (Reply to #3)
dazed and seeki...
dazed and seeking peace and strength's picture

If I don't respond, will he stop pursuing me?

I have been his longest relationship. He has been with countless women, and he has never stuck around this long for any of them. Back in September, he moved to a different country for a job, and he is still hanging on to this. Do narcs hold on to ALL of their supply? I mean he could be reaching out to a ton other women, why me? If I don't respond, what do you think he will do? Just stop, because he realizes this source of supply has dried up? I apologize for all of the questions. I want a clear head if I were to reach out to him. So far I have no incentive for reaching out to him, other than to see how badly he wants to see me - because the next opportunity is my spring break in 2 weeks. Other than that, if nothing happens, I think I am ready to move on for good. Half of me aches to see him and to forget about everything, and half of me is telling me to SPRINT forward and to never look back. This is such an exhausting process - to be dealing with an alleged narc. Because with any other person, I could simply pick up the phone and have a conversation and work something out.
Feb 22 - 8AM (Reply to #7)
Disillusionedx2
Disillusionedx2's picture

more wishful, hopeful thinking

Dear, you're going to need to stop and put it all into perspective here, you're still unsure, not uncommon, speaking about reaching out when he's left you in the dust during your worst moments, reach out for what? To make yourself feel better? Or perhaps you are special; sure, to get mistreated, you're the special one he wants to hurl insults at and blame all that is wrong with the relationship on you, forget about him and worry about you! Who cares if he will stop pursuing if you don't answer? Yes, eventually he will move on, probably already have, and best believe there is fresh and old supply on the hook. I discovered N had so many woman I lost count, he had a mobile phone of mine, I'm thinking he's home in bed, or just what he tell me he's doing or where he claimed to be, he was doing the exact opposite, had over 400 phone numbers in contacts, I went online and looked was calling, dating and doing only GOD knows what else with a good portion of them, got the phone out of his custody, still fielding calls for him to this day, I thought I was special too, NOT by a long shot, move on, save yourself any further heart ache, they do not change, except supply sources!

stay~strong

Feb 22 - 5AM (Reply to #6)
agnesmurphy17
agnesmurphy17's picture

For all you know

he's sending the same e-mails to other women at the same time. He's bored. Alone. Got a few minutes. You really have no idea. You think you're special. Maybe you are. Maybe not. I found out mine was "juggling" -- sending me love letters, seeking reconciliation WHILE he was courting another woman with whom he was practically living. And, everytime they had an argument, he called me asking me out to dinner. How do I know this? After she left him, she contacted me & I showed her all my e-mails from him. We charted the whole trajectory of his lies.
Feb 22 - 1AM (Reply to #5)
justicejones
justicejones's picture

I would have to agree with

I would have to agree with Happydays... Stay NC. For your own sanity. I have said to others that Narc have no enemies, just old supply sources. They will come back as long as they can get a response; positive or negative from you. My ex husband left my children and I almost five years ago. During our marriage, I would leave him and he would beg, plead etc to get me back. At first he wouldn't...he would be mad at me, but then, it would hit him and I think he got scared that I was moving on and he would start the begging and promises. The last time he left, he left the mainland and went to Hawaii. I didn't hear from him but maybe a couple of times, but he wouldn't let on where he was. One factor, is he had warrants here...btw. But I remember trying to piece together why he wasn't trying to beg to come back...well, he had found a more convenient source in Hawaii. She put up with all the things I didn't like him doing and didn't expect him to change or tow the line. Well, I found him and contacted him...then quess what? First of all he denied being with the OW. But then he would say how sorry he was and wanted to come back, face his warrants and be a good dad and husband. He would beg me not to divorce him. Then he would go days without calling and not answering my calls or text. But after a while he would call back and start the hoovering again. This was when things were going bad with the OW. He also wanted to make sure I still wanted him and was waiting for him. What he did was go to his home state with the new woman after only being with her for four months, instead of coming home like he promised to a wife he had had for seven years. They had babies, and I didn't hear from him for years. I had changed my number. Fast forward to this last fall. He was extradited back here for not paying child support and guess who was writing me from jail? Him! Asking to pick up where we had left off like he had never left and proclaiming his undying love for me etc. Yeah, well come to find out, him and the OW's marriage had yet again fallen on drama filled-bad times and she had left him. So since he was back in town, he thought he would try to look me up, hook me up and suck me back in. I cannot lie, it brought back lots of those old feelings and I did start believing some of his junk...but thanks to this site, I kept my head on straight. So, there you go, my dear. It's a pattern. They may leave you alone for a while...but the best bet is to refuse contact with them and eventually they will go onto an easier, more convenient source.
Feb 22 - 12AM (Reply to #4)
happydaysahead
happydaysahead's picture

Well, I will say this........

I have been on here for about a year now and I am still learning new things all the time. As far as suppply, they will hang onto whatever they have for as long as THEY want. It has nothing to do with feelings or caring about us. They just like the feel of importance. If you don't respond, well he may turn up the *charm* or he may get pissed off, but it really doesn't matter what happens, it will not be real. It is just another tool they use to manipulate you/us. Without trying to sound like a bitch here, PLEASE DO NOT REACH OUT TO HIM OR CONTACT HIM. It will do you absolutely NO good, but will just make you feel worse and will just prolong this sick little game he is playing with you. You will NEVER be able to talk to him like a *normal* person, because they are not normal people. They will just play you over and over again until they are tired or bored with the game and then we are left behind, trying to pick up the pieces. They never look back, they never feel remorse or sorry. I know it sounds harsh and I know it sucks, but it is what it is and we just tear ourselves up trying to figure it out, trying to figure out what WE did wrong or what WE can do to make it better. But, there is nothing we can do because there is nothing we have done. Make sense ?? For your own well being, you just need to break away and stay away. It will be hard, but it the only thing we can do to salvage what is left of our self esteem. In the long run and in time, you will be able to look back and you will be SO much happier !! Hugs !!