A Eulogy for My Professor

15 posts / 0 new
Last post
#1 Oct 11 - 1AM
Susan32
Susan32's picture

A Eulogy for My Professor

Today, let us pay the final respects to CT, the man I thought you were. Long ago, I once read your manuscripts with glee, thinking you were my equal, that you cherished me as one, and that you were my mentor who cared. I mourn those days when I could read what you said about Wittgenstein, Tolstoy, and the meaning of life (with St. Augustine in for good measure), and you were the caring guy. I mourn the professor who cared about my intellect, who was willing to engage with me philosophically, who saw me as a human being. I mourn the loss of those smiles... which apparently you only had in my presence. Yes, you were my mentor and my father figure, but I also saw you as another of my friends, someone in whom I confided and trusted. Someone who had my best interests in mind. I mourn that person.

Philosophers have spoken of the "death of an illusion" (the real you was full of others' quotations, nothing of your own)... and this is what I mourn today. I cared for that young philosopher, full of potential, who seemed to care about God and the big scheme of things. What's particularly sad about this gathering today is that the deceased never existed. In those final days, the real you said that I was the one who was projecting my compassion, kindness, and patience onto you. And this is who we are burying today. The real you admitted that the one we lay to rest today is an illusion, an act. What could be more sadder than that?

I lost a teacher today. As for his soul (if he still has one), let us pray for that.

Oct 12 - 2PM
helldweller
helldweller's picture

Susan

Your eulogy made me honestly sob. You reminded me about something I'd forgotten about the narc. I have been writing that he is not interested in anything, but long ago, when we first met, I saw that he had once and truly wanted to be a great lawyer. His favorite book (probably the only one he ever read except for Chicago true crime and corruption books) was "To Kill a Mockingbird," and he had a framed letter from Harper Lee on his piano. He had written to her to tell her how much he loved the book, and she wrote back, "Judge Narc, it was an honor to receive your kind letter . . . " Our first Christmas, I gave him a replica of the Montgomery, Alabama courthouse that had inspired Lee in writing the book. He had a tear in his eye--a real one, I think. I also remember now, about the piano, that his brother had given it years ago to him because he wanted to learn to play. He said he couldn't keep the rhythm and gave it up. I am remembering a lot of things now that I'd forgotten: that he mentioned liking Frank Lloyd Wright, Elton John, that he had some antique toy cars in his old kitchen. I remember thinking that nothing seemed part of him: as if these things were tokens of attempts at having interests, hobbies, things he loved. I remember thinking, at the end, that he vaguely seemed as if he were a very old man, remembering bits of his life and not living it anymore, as someone might remember his dead wife's perfume or driving his first car in the Summer long ago. I used to think, romantically, that his failed engagement had killed him inside--until I realized that he had made it fail on purpose.
Oct 12 - 6PM (Reply to #14)
Susan32
Susan32's picture

"Remembering bits of his life&not living it anymore"

Thanks for your beautiful words, Helldweller. Your words resonated with me as well... what you said about your Narc can very well apply to mine. The ex-Psych professor, like your Narc, talked about wanting to play the piano... but he never stuck with it. He took lessons, but they didn't last. He dabbled in tennis with a fellow professor&his wife (that didn't last) and skiing. He didn't even have pets, unlike a lot of bachelors. "He vaguely seemed as if he were a very old man, remembering bits of his life¬ living it anymore"- Weird. All of us here talk about how Ns/Ps experience time differently... living in the moment. Yet you also show the nostalgic aspect. The ex-P seemed prematurely old to me, tho he D&D'd me when he was only 36... and I was replaced with a curator (how telling!) There's such a disconnect. When I lived in the moment, when I was enjoying life... he always had an aura of frustration and anger.
Oct 11 - 10PM
moonshine
moonshine's picture

susan

This is beautiful the way you have expressed yet melancholic. Actually this letter expresses more of him than any other posts that you have written explaining of him. It comes from deep with in your heart as i feel. I wish you all the best.
Oct 16 - 10PM (Reply to #12)
Susan32
Susan32's picture

Because the feelings were real... VERY real...

Though I never got physically/romantically intimate with the ex-P, I thought I was being emotionally intimate. In some twisted way, he was as vulnerable to me as I was to him. I could feel his sadness, his anger, his disappointment, his fear/paranoia, his envy, his insecurity. Of course, he DENIED all of those, but I basically sensed the basic trifecta of feelings of a narcissist: anger, fear, envy. I saw a handsome young man with potential... potential that he squandered. Writing this eulogy was purifying and making sense of the past.
Oct 11 - 10AM
outoftheblue
outoftheblue's picture

When I was in law school,

When I was in law school, there were rumors that a fellow student was having an affair with an older, married professor. I have absolutely no idea if it was true or not, and I was not in class with them. I did hear that the way he spoke to her in class was somewhat inappropriate and there were definitely whispers behind her back. I didn't know her well and probably judged her for it. She got an 'A' in that class, I only know this from the grumbling about it. This happened our first year, the rumors persisted until we graduated. I think we were all of 22 at the time. This must have been very difficult for her, and for you too. When an authority figure acts inappropriately, there are definite consequences. Look at Monica Lewinsky! Poor thing, who would have thought a BJ could have almost taken down a presidency? She was vilified in the media, she wasn't innocent but she didn't deserve the beating she got either. Ultimately it was Clinton who behaved badly and she was left to fend for herself at such a young age. I hope that you find it within yourself to let go of the pain. He is not worth the anguish you put yourself through. Hopefully you can close this chapter of your life and move past it. What he did sucked, no doubt about it. It sounds like you have moved away from anywhere where you would be associated with it, so you can make a clean break.
Oct 11 - 10AM (Reply to #10)
Susan32
Susan32's picture

It happened a decade ago...

Here's the sad irony, the D&D was happening DURING the Monica Lewinsky scandal. The ex-Psych professor and I NEVER got sexually/romantically involved, but people assumed we were. He ended up ditching me for his curator girlfriend from LA, who moved in with him, married him, had his kids so he could look like Mr. Normal Family Man. I left New Mexico a decade ago... he hasn't communicated with me since. I left without telling a soul, not even the professors I trusted the most. He didn't even have the guts to fake an apology, like some Ns/Ps do. The ex-P had a bad reputation as a professor too. During the D&D, when he was publicly rebuking me and reducing me to tears, he was teaching a class on Shakespeare's Sonnets. Ironically, it was the least popular one. From all I heard,it was mainly drinking wine at various venues off-campus. I'm glad it never got sexual or romantic. People thought we were that way, but we weren't. To make things awkward, it was an openly gay professor (with whom he apparently had a brief affair), warned me about the ex-P's dark side. The ex-P had a circle of male disciples with whom he might've been more than a mentor figure. One of them went so far as to move to Oregon and change his name. I feel like I'm coming to terms with the past. The ex-P was a total coward and liar. Still is. At the time, he liked the fact that he lived far from his parents and was on his own. He had gone to college in Massachusetts where his father was his professor, and did grad school in New York and Virginia, so he had a short leash. Going to New Mexico was the first time he was far from his parents and off his own (at the ripe age of 32) But I found out 9 years ago that his parents had moved in with him to raise his kids... and by extension, him. Playtime is over.
Oct 11 - 9AM
jen79
jen79's picture

Susan

this is 9 years ago, right? I was told by many friends and family the same, dont think about it now, you can grieve later, dont dont dont. Well I couldnt, I lost everything, but still I think, it was the right the decision to fully take a time out to process all what happened. It scared me to hear from women, who experiences similar things, that after years they still felt this deep pain about them, though they were married and had children... I think your case and so many other cases too, show us, you cant run away from that grief and pain, you do have to put yourself through it, or this will haunt you like a dark shadow for the rest of your life. I am so thankfull for this side, it gives me so much understanding...and my stomach doesnt pain so much any more, and I can breath again...
Oct 13 - 9PM (Reply to #8)
Susan32
Susan32's picture

Going into the labyrinth

In the myth of Theseus, the heroic son of Poseidon ventures into the labyrinth to battle the Minotaur, which had devoured the virginal Athenians. I've felt like I've had to do the same. After the D&D, I was basically told to hurry up and move on. I even had friends tell me NOT to be angry and NOT think about the mind-screwing I went through. It's like I had been in a catastrophic accident, and expected to walk away&go back to work after extensive bleeding and broken limbs. Then I spent 5 years in a toxic/narcissistic workplace with a Narc boss... and I was in pure survival mode. I really didn't face the past. I was too busy trying to survive. In the past 2 years, I've been in a better workplace. A former coworker of mine has recently been hired, and he validated how bad that place was.... after I was fired, a cook was arrested for drugs&having a gun, not to mention assaulting the manager. There are people there who can't drive due to violence charges. I'm relaxed enough to face the past. I have the serenity to contemplate. Recently, I was reading parts of "War and Peace",with its narcissistic lead Prince Andrei. The ex-Psych professor identified very much with him. Andrei is described as "incapable of tears." He abandons his wife Princess Lise, mocks her religion, then gets to engaged to- and rejects Princess Natasha. He's conscious of how he has hurt them. Lise, the victim of Andrei's narcissistic treatment, is mocked by the author at her funeral. Andrei has contempt for most of humanity, he believes the ill should be left to die, and when he's dying, he forbids his loved ones from weeping, even his 7 year old son. He says he believes in eternal Love, that by dying he will be united with eternal Love... yet he knowingly treats Natasha and Lise cruelly. Even on his deathbed, he has contempt for human emotions and dismisses them as trivial. He thinks his hatred of emotions makes him superior to other humans. Tolstoy explains Andrei's life as a living death... even when he's very much alive and debating philosophy with Prince Pierre. How very true! Just like the sparkly vegetarian vampire Edward Cullen and Mr. Darcy, Prince Andrei is an object of literary fangirl infatuation. The ex-Psych professor identified with Prince Andrei Bolkonsky... and Andrei is a FICTIONAL character. Gives a whole new meaning to that book title "Narcissism and the False Self."
Oct 11 - 8AM
MsVulcan500
MsVulcan500's picture

Susan,

This is very nice. Did it help you feel better? I especially like the line "the deceased never existed." More true words have never been spoken.
Oct 11 - 9AM (Reply to #2)
Susan32
Susan32's picture

Very helpful

At the time, I never really got a chance to grieve. I was really rushed at the time. I was told to not think about it, just move on... yeah, as if pretending it didn't happen is helpful.
Oct 11 - 9AM (Reply to #3)
MsVulcan500
MsVulcan500's picture

Susan,

Jen said it very well, that just stuffing it away does not make it go away. Sure, you can go on for years thinking everything is okay, and for the most part it is, but then BAM! It manifests again somehow and you are back at the beginning again. You are the perfect example of this. Someone said, "You can't just get over it, you need to go through it." I truly believe this.
Oct 11 - 9AM (Reply to #4)
Susan32
Susan32's picture

Triggers

I've dealt with some triggers lately. A former classmate of mine died last year. She was only 40, she died in her sleep. Why do I bring her up? In my freshman year, the ex-Psych professor pitted her and I against each other. We went from being nearly friends to her believing all the garbage he told her about me. She stayed behind to be a professor, to teach choir. A decade ago, during the D&D, I dreamt that she and I had met a college reunion, and were able to reconcile and forgive each other. Her death last year was very sudden, very triggering. She had been closer to the ex-P than me. The COD remains unknown... so lack of closure. Eerily, I thought "That could've been me" and "I hope it was from natural causes."
Oct 11 - 10AM (Reply to #5)
MsVulcan500
MsVulcan500's picture

Triggers

Right, those triggers come up, but if we've gone through the process, they will not trip us up so badly. That's why it's so important to really work through it and do that hard work. So I am happy you are doing that even now. And yes, you and that former classmate probably could have reconciled and maybe even been friends. And if not, at least put all of the animosity the psych-professor created to rest. I had a friend who basically drank herself to death, and I am still trying to figure out my XN's part in it. It's something I may have to write about, but at this time I am still trying to figure it all out and get my head wrapped around it a bit.
Oct 11 - 10AM (Reply to #6)
Susan32
Susan32's picture

Survivor Guilt

I feel like someone who's gone through a catastrophe, crawling out of the wreckage and one of the few left alive. It was unclear whether the classmate was still a professor, or if she had died in New Mexico (where she was a professor) or in her home state of Washington. The ex-P's male followers seem to have dropped off the face of the Earth. I was friends with one of them... and he has since changed his name, given up philosophy, and moved to Oregon. Very odd. (and he was DEFINITELY closer to the ex-P than me, the ex-P was his senior essay advisor,apparently knew the ex-P's sister in Texas) Somehow I made it out alive. Scarred and shocked... but alive.