Should I e-mail his dad?

20 posts / 0 new
Last post
#1 Jul 21 - 11AM
Amy
Amy's picture

Should I e-mail his dad?

I am having a harder time with how I feel about the ex N's dad than I am with him.

His father was sooooo excited when we got engaged. He is a great person, and I worry that he will the poorly of me. There is a part of me that wants to e-mail him and tell him I am sorry that it didn't work out, and that I wish him and his family the best. I actually don't know if he will think I did something wrong, as he knows his son is difficult for me to deal with.

My concern is that his dad will tell him, and it will be seen as me reaching out. It is a difficult decision - as I really care about his father.

Thoughts?

Jul 21 - 8PM
naivenomore
naivenomore's picture

Yes, go for it!

Amy, I would e-mail his Dad if you need that closure and had a good rapport with him. Remember, it's not about HIM (the N), it's about you and another person ;-)
Jul 21 - 8PM
betty2020
betty2020's picture

Amy, If you feel honey that

Amy, If you feel honey that you really need to say your goodbyes then go ahead and do that. Hold no expectations to what reaction you will get from him however, make it short, to the point and then part ways. Dont worry if he tells the N. If you feel this is the closure you need then do it for you dear. Just make sure the motive is in the right place. Understand that when you say your goodbye it is for good. Over and done. Walk out and on with your life sweetie. I talked about this connection in the sense of keeping contact with Ns family, friends and objects in order to keep a connection to the N. We all know this is not good for us. As much as we dont like it, deep down we know its unhealthy. Sometimes we just have to be honest with ourselves and take a good hard look at our motives behind our thoughts and actions. I had to change many things i was doing because my motives were not in check. Sleep on it tonight and if you still feel the same tomorrow then maybe you should go thru with it. only one way to go...Forward (tm?)

only one way to go...Forward (tm?)

Jul 21 - 8PM
NancyM
NancyM's picture

I did

When I was a few weeks NC I rang his oldest daughter and told her I was cutting all contact. She sounded nervous speaking to me and I knew the smear campaign was in full swing by this time. I told her that I did not have anything to tell her about why I was cutting contact, but it was just something I had to do. I asked her not to take it personally, sent my love to her and her sisters, and told her to pass the message to her mother that I finally got it. I did this for myself because I felt savage cutting them all out with no explanation. I have no doubt they believe Daddy's freaked out stories and personally, I don't care.

Nevergoback

Jul 21 - 8PM (Reply to #13)
Amy
Amy's picture

I don't know that his dad

I don't know that his dad would believe a smear campaign. And I don't know that he would start one - given that he always wants to look like he is a good person. I am still on the fence with this issue.
Jul 21 - 8PM (Reply to #14)
NancyM
NancyM's picture

Smear campaign

"given that he always wants to look like he is a good person" is the exact reason why the smear campaign starts. Sounds like his Dad knows what he is like though so he may be wasting his time trying. Just remember how insidious and covert they can be. Little comments...suggestions, and leaving things only half said always leaves the target wondering what the truth really is. Also blood is thicker than water.

Nevergoback

Jul 22 - 12PM (Reply to #17)
rainbow1
rainbow1's picture

"Little

"Little comments...suggestions, and leaving things only half said always leaves the target wondering what the truth really is." That is the story of my life with the N! I swear that one sentence summed it all up for me! Leaving things half said or only partly answering a question was how mine would keep me confused. I never knew where we stood or how he felt. I was always in a state of confusion!

_______________________________________________
"dont let yesterday take up too much of today"

Jul 21 - 8PM (Reply to #15)
Amy
Amy's picture

Oh I totally agree

That blood is thicker than water. I don't want to get his dad "on my side", just want to say goodbye. But I am afraid of doing anything that isn't in my best interests.
Jul 21 - 8PM (Reply to #16)
NancyM
NancyM's picture

Then I agree with Lisa on

Then I agree with Lisa on this one...say goodbye now and ask him not to say anything about it to N. It will give you a little closure on not leaving something undone in my opinion.

Nevergoback

Jul 21 - 1PM
Lisa E. Scott
Lisa E. Scott's picture

Amy

Oh, I know what you're going through. It's so difficult to say goodbye to the family members in his life that you grew close to, but it has to be done. If you're going to do it, do it now and make it clear that you are only reaching out to say goodbye and ask that he not say anything to n. I think that's the best approach. xoxo
Jul 21 - 12PM
Janet
Janet's picture

It is so hard to have to let

It is so hard to have to let go of the people you care about who are more connected with the N than with you. N has a son, to whom I was like a step mom to for 4 years. When N D&Ded it was over with the little boy too. The last contact I had with him was a Christmas present (something he had eyed a few months earlier) and a letter from me telling how much I missed him and loved him. I did not know this would be the final contact. But, a blood relation is "their" person. It has to be over with them as well. Whether it is one last letter or call to say goodbye. It is very sad how much pain these people cause to nearly everyone who comes in contact with them. Good luck. Peace. J

Peace. J

Jul 21 - 12PM
broken23
broken23's picture

"I am having a harder time

"I am having a harder time with how I feel about the ex N's dad than I am with him" I think I have told Lisa this and my therapist. That the most traumatic experience wasnt losing him but losing the family, and them being told lies, and me wanting to just tell them the truth, and have their support. My personal two cents. I would reach out once if you want...and say what you have to say because it will lift a weight from your shoulder by doing the right thing...but it is probably not to have a good idea to keep a ongoing relationship since it keeps you in the loop about his life and also his dad mentioning you called. Also be honest with your expectations. If you are calling because you want his father to be on your side, well thats his father...he cannot cut off N, no matter how horrible they are. He might not even want to believe some of the horrible things about his son. Also know that this relationship has ended so essentially what his father thinks of you does not matter in the long run. your only tie to him was your N. I know its so hard, I have grieved the loss of the love of N's family...they really do tear apart every relationship and hurt so many people...and they dont care.
Jul 21 - 12PM (Reply to #9)
betty2020
betty2020's picture

We all feel tremendous loss

We all feel tremendous loss when the relationship ends. We grieve the N, the family members, friends and all connections associate. This is only natural. But at some point we have to get honest with ourselves that it IS over. We have to internally say our good byes, put them all on that bus and drive it off the cliff. only one way to go...Forward (tm?)

only one way to go...Forward (tm?)

Jul 21 - 11AM
betty2020
betty2020's picture

Its another connection Amy.

Its another connection Amy. Dont contact him. Read the post about having a connection to the N. xoxooxo only one way to go...Forward (tm?)

only one way to go...Forward (tm?)

Jul 21 - 11AM (Reply to #4)
Amy
Amy's picture

yeah....

trying not to have a connection there. I just feel so bad about his dad. It is definitely a conflicting issue!
Jul 22 - 7AM (Reply to #7)
Used
Used's picture

amy

i agree with betty, dont contact his dad, the narc will find out and think you are doin it to get to him,and anyway why, if his dad is bothered why hasent he contacted you, even if he does know his, blood is thicker than water, he is still his son.
Jul 21 - 12PM (Reply to #5)
betty2020
betty2020's picture

Im sorry but i dont

Im sorry but i dont understand why you feel so sorry for his father? Could you explain this in more detail? xoxo only one way to go...Forward (tm?)

only one way to go...Forward (tm?)

Jul 21 - 12PM (Reply to #6)
Amy
Amy's picture

This was

This was his dad's wish - for us to get married. He loves my son and I, and always gave the N a hard time about it when we were apart. He was hoping his son would get married some day, and always thought I was sweet to him and the family. I spent a lot of time cooking with him - learned all the family recipes. It is just so sad. He knows there is something wrong with N, but not exactly what. It is not my intent to tell him, I just kinda want to say goodbye, ya know? Interestingly, N doesn't get along with his sister at all. Hates her and has called her the C word. Even says his niece and nephew are stupid (sad). He says when his dad dies he will never see or speak to his sister again.
Jul 21 - 11AM
rainbow1
rainbow1's picture

Amy

I still talk to my ex N's dad all of the time. He is a great guy. He doesnt tell his son anything that I say and promises that he wont. He knows that his son is a handful. He still has hopes that his son and I will be together one day. His dad loves me and actually was mad at his son for a while after the break up. He still thinks differently of his son for leaving me. His dad being on my side actually helps me. He checks up on me all of the time and it makes me feel better :) I think that emailing him and showing that you care isnt a bad thing. I would go for it if you want to!

_______________________________________________
"dont let yesterday take up too much of today"

Jul 21 - 11AM
helldweller
helldweller's picture

Amy

Gosh. This is really tough. I understand that you care the dad and feel terribly about the break and want him to know it wasn't because of you. I was sort of in a similar situation with my narc. I tried to get his brothers to help me get him to counseling--after he was driving drunk with his foster child in the car, after he took the child with him to spend the week with another woman and lied about it, after he beat me up. They just think I'm nuts. The problem is not that my narc tells them another side of the story, but that, having known him for so long, the family has given up on him. At least that's in my case. With a narc, you never know what the family thinks of him or if they would be open to defending you or even keeping the secret of your contact. The emails I sent to my n's brother were never answered. I found out later that he would just print them out and dutifullly give them to my narc. What a good little soldier, right? Sick. I don't know what the dad would do; if he would tell the narc. I don't even know if you could guess. I think if you're going to do it, do it now, and try your very best to make it clear to the dad that you are not going back to him under any circumstances, and to please honor your request to not say anything. Nothing against women, but I think moms are more inclined to try to patch things up by telling. Men have a better idea of when to say nothing, especially when they are told not to. I think women say a lot of stuff they've been asked not to because they "mean well." Okay. Covering my ears waiting for the accusations of sexism. Sorry!