The Silent Treatment

21 posts / 0 new
Last post
#1 Aug 23 - 9AM
RM
RM's picture

The Silent Treatment

Could someone explain why this works-why when receiving the silent treatment we want him even more?

Thanks

Aug 24 - 11AM
Deidre40
Deidre40's picture

I agree w/everyone. It’s

I agree w/everyone. It’s designed to punish. (from the narc’s perspective) Also, I suffered the silent treatment as a kid, when family would get angry with me over things normal kids do. Ugh. Which is why it ‘felt normal’ to me, with the narcs I’ve dated. But, love should not be painful like this. I also wanted to add that NC shouldn’t be confused with silent treatment. When WE AS VICTIMS go NC against our ex n’s…it is NOT like their version of the silent treatment. Just thought that’s important to point out. NC is about our healing, and not about punishing them. Although, they will take it as such, when they can’t pull your heartstrings anymore! Keep strong…
Aug 24 - 4PM (Reply to #19)
Totally Stunned
Totally Stunned's picture

Deidre40

I am glad you brought this up, because I think about this everyday of my No Contact. Seriously. We didnt officially end our relationship. He never officially broke up with me. He just never called me back after our last encounter. I gave my Narc a second chance after he did break up the first time months ago. He wormed his way back into my heart which was not tough to do. I was SO ready to take him back. By the time we saw eachother again in person - we were intimate and it was so much more than sex to me. I gave him my heart, my love, my total attention while he complained about his family. I gave him a shoulder to cry on, my understanding. We live 1,000 miles from eachother, and at the airport he just kissed me goodbye. That was it. I never heard from him ever again, and I TOOK THAT TO BE HIM LEAVING ME. I mean, seriously, its been 4 weeks since that kiss goodbye. Now. By me NOT calling him either - I never thought that I was giving him the silent treatment, it was my way of healing. By NOT chasing him. When 2 weeks went by and I never heard from him...I felt used. But then it occured to me. Could HE be thinking to himself, "well, she never contacted me?" I am SO confused. My NO CONTACT is to do the 6 steps for healing. Not as a punishment. Could he be thinking that I am giving him the silent treatment by mistake?
Aug 24 - 5PM (Reply to #20)
Deidre40
Deidre40's picture

Hello TS--I'm sorry this

Hello TS--I'm sorry this happened to you. :=( May I ask...have you tried contacting him? Like if I got together with someone, and they departed at the airport...I'd probably call. And if my calls went unreturned for weeks...then, I'd wonder for sure what happened. Is this a pattern for him? If so, then it's the silent treatment. It sounds a lot like one of the poster's stories here, ''dabussard,'' is her name. I'm hoping she'll chime in. Her ex would give her the moon, and then go silent for a week. No explanation, except that he's an asshole. lol
Aug 23 - 3PM
Susan32
Susan32's picture

Primary supply

For the ex-Psych prof, his fellow profs and students were sources of primary supply (yet as a student, I managed to be primary AND secondary, despite the fact I was NEITHER his girlfriend nor wife)... and he gave them the silent treatment too. During senior oral examinations, he'd fidget. Once, during a senior oral exam on "The Producers",he went off on a tangent about the homoerotic connection between the Zero Mostel&Gene Wilder characters. His fellow profs heroically resisted rolling their eyes en masse. He'd zone out during conversations. His colleagues treated him like an annoying toddler they were forced to deal with. (If you see exasperated parents with a tantrum-throwing toddler at an airport, think of his colleagues being like that) He ignored a prof who was older than him,and a social equal, because this PROF CALLED HIM BY HIS FIRST NAME. This prof was MALE, to boot. He was infamous for going on bizarre tangents in class. During the final D&D, I saw him pacing around like a restless toddler, not even giving eye contact to his advisee/male disciple. I wasn't the only he completely disregarded. He did the same thing to a fellow senior who was working on his senior thesis. And a MALE. I can't fall back on the "he's punishing me because of his Mommy" because he gave the silent treatment to males.
Aug 23 - 2PM
BadaBing
BadaBing's picture

form of abandonment

Hi I don't know all the exact details but silent treatment is a passive aggressive more with more emphasis on 'aggressive' that is intended to shun and hurt the person being silenced. It can be incredbily hurtful because it is INTENTIONAL , and when employed the intention is to hurt or punish for something why does it make you want him even more? because you are in detox, like a drug addict. The narc causes intenses surges of chemicals in our brain that feel really good but when suddently taken away - we go into withdrawl and think about 'the love we shared' - this is a detoxing process. Read up on this disorder. I didn't really understand how much of a Narc I was dealing with until I started to read up on this subject/issue sending you support
Aug 23 - 12PM
Used
Used's picture

silence

for me ,this was his undoing...as i already had abandament issue [he didnt know this]...the first time he dissappeared after a full on seeing each every day for months....i went in to shock...the first week i kept thinking...i cant cope without him...how will i cope? but as time went on irelized i could cope..and he was the one who told me i couldnt cope without him....he came back of course....i never even mention it...just went back to what it was...but i knew without a shadow of a doubt i was going to get out.....it took me years, he still went off..but when he came back..i then went off and so on...he would ask me how long has it been since we last saw each other...i would say i havent got a clue...why narc have you been counting the days...my parents seperatly done this to me all my childhood then adult years, this scumbag wasent going to do it as well...and each time i went back i liked him less and less...i went back until i couldnt bear him within 10 feet of me...i never sat facing him...i never stood facing him....then i dropped him for good... wise words said to me....PEOPLE GIVE UP THEIR POWER WHEN THEY LEAVE YOU FOR TOO LONG....MY PARENTS DID ,HE DID..AND NWOMEN DID....I DROPPED THEM ALL AND DONT REGRET IT.... i am a believer in do unto others ,what they do to you...i did..my father is now dead...the 3narcs left still try to communicate....NO WAY JOSE...THEY STARTED IT...I FINISHED IT....SILENT TREATMENT FOR THEM IS THE ONLY WAY TO GO...THEY ARE CRUEL SADISTIC BASTARDS.
Aug 23 - 2PM (Reply to #15)
Layla
Layla's picture

I agree with this post 100%!

My abuser N husband left me emotionally months before I physically kicked him out....8 years together...his final D&D to me was to ignore me and the silent treatment.....I would literally be trying to talk to him and he would sit at his computer acting like I wasn't even there at all! It was awful, it was so humiliating! This was the ONE person that was supposed to love, honor and cherish me! his actions spoke toward NONE OF THAT. I was emotionally detached long before he was even gone. Now we have been about 10 weeks NC.....although he has tried....I just really am so angry still....I am not even sad or "longing"....just pissed off and working through this nightmare and working on my own personal healing.....he did me a FAVOR with the silent treatment.....he really did. The final nail in this abusing big mouth's coffin was ironically no words at all..........
Aug 23 - 12PM (Reply to #14)
Hunter
Hunter's picture

Used

I love, " they started it I finished it" Rock On Hunter
Aug 23 - 12PM
dazedandcnonfused
dazedandcnonfused's picture

thats how I found this forum

My ex is the master of the silent treatment. It makes me crazy and confused. Im left apologizing for things I am not even sure for what. I am not 100% sure if he is a narc...but I started to google the silent treatment and did a lot of reading that led me to narcissism characteristics. Hence finding this great site. Anyhow I believe my ex gives me the silent treatment because he knows that it makes me upset. We have a long distance relationship so when he goes silent I have no way to know if he is OK. I also have abandonment issues when it comes to him and he knows this. So it only feeds on the pain when he ignores me. I think I read somewhere that they figure out really quick what will work on that person. And for me it really is the only control he has over me...and that is blessing me with his attention...puke!
Aug 23 - 1PM (Reply to #7)
Totally Stunned
Totally Stunned's picture

Hello Dazedandconfused. I

Hello Dazedandconfused. I think I responded to you on another topic - it seems we have alot in common with our Narcs. My Narc has used the silent treatment on me several times - this one is by FAR the worst though - and my head KNOWS him to be the messed up sick f^ck that he really is. My heart? Well, my heart hasnt caught up with my head just yet. I remember also telling my narc when we were going through that idealization/honeymoon stage that the worst thing he could ever do to me is give me the silent treatment. Funny that he was looking for information he could use against me later on. What an ass! Being given the silent treatment lead me to learn about narcissism and then I found this forum, just like you. I really believe that this is the last one I can take. I KNOW in both my heart and my head he will NEVER EVER call me or text me. Not this time...he has used up all of his charm and I am no use to him any longer. So....lets stick together and start the healing process!!!
Aug 24 - 1AM (Reply to #12)
ifinallygotit
ifinallygotit's picture

thats what I thought too

but a year after the abandonment he came back to town, called, texted, acted like my BF totally f__ed up my mind and then disappeared again after he went back to work in his city - you never know when they are done because the things they do make no sense- we need to decide when we are finished...I pray that I get over a crazy person
Aug 23 - 2PM (Reply to #8)
dazedandcnonfused
dazedandcnonfused's picture

Yes!!! I am in the process

Yes!!! I am in the process of healing. Like you said though my heart and brain havent quite joined forces yet. I am hoping during this silent time that I will gain the tools I need to stay strong. I am still fooled by a fantasy of who I wish he was and need to realize that is not reality. He is gone...he is not a good person...and he doesnt deserve my time and energy. I just hope that I can get over him while being on this forum. Or is this contributing to my obsession of him?
Aug 23 - 2PM (Reply to #10)
Hunter
Hunter's picture

Dazdd

All good questions.. Being obsessed with us ( people who care about you ) is better than being obsessed with him! Spinning is 100% correct! Keep this great buzz alive !! It's working! There will be a point where you won't need us anymore!! Then we pop the champagne, and say goodbye!! Hunter
Aug 23 - 3PM (Reply to #11)
dazedandcnonfused
dazedandcnonfused's picture

I am thankful for the

I am thankful for the connections I have made on this forum. I am looking at this as the positive side of the madness. You are all wonderful! But dont say goodbye!!! Remember I have abandonment issues:( I dont even like saying goodbye to my patients when they leave the hospital. grrhh...goodbyes seem so permanent!
Aug 23 - 2PM (Reply to #9)
spinning
spinning's picture

Dazed, the short answer is

no. This is where you learn, learn, learn and process and get it out. Working the six steps works! It does. Being on this forum is not about him, it's all about YOU and all about US. That's where the power is! Great work so far, dazed. You'll learn and recognize so much you won't even want to get within 10 miles of a disordered situation ever again!! Hugs to you and good vibes for continued strength and clarity from, (not) spinning. NEVER THOUGHT IT WOULD BE POSSIBLE BUT NOW I WILL NEVER EVER SPIN AGAIN FOR ANY MAN...FOR ANY ONE!

spinning

Aug 23 - 11AM
spinning
spinning's picture

RM, the silent treatment

is a horrific form of abuse. It is designed to negate your being, to render you invisible, and the longing stems from the very human desire to be acknowledged. It is my sincere hope that after you read and consider this, the "wanting" feeling for someone who gives you the silent treatment will diminish. The freak I was involved with was the KING OF SILENT TREATMENT. The more I read about it, the more I realized how truly horrible it was and the more I wanted to stay away from him. To continue with someone who would invoke the silent treatment at a whim was to continue to destroy and deny myself. Here it is, braveheart. I hope it helps. http://abuse101.com/silenttreatmentandabuse.html Most sincerely, (not) spinning. NEVER AGAIN. THE SICK FREAK BELONGS IN THE ZOO AND NO WHERE NEAR MY HEAD.

spinning

Aug 23 - 11AM
dabussard
dabussard's picture

Silent Treatment

Oh, the silent treatment used to hurt me so bad... It is a way to drop our self esteem.. My N used to give me a blissful week with all kinds of attention and affection.. Once, he brought me up and I was on cloud 9, bam along came the silent treatment... When you love someone, you want to be with them and talk to them daily... Mine used to say, yea it makes you want me more... You were getting too comfortable with me.. Plus, in my experience, when he was silent, he was with another woman.. Damn Jacknuts Anyway!!!
Aug 23 - 10AM
Hunter
Hunter's picture

I'm the silent treatment

I'm the silent treatment queen! I've come to realize they use what works! For me Hoovering would set me off! I would not put up with it for one minute! He knows it! My friend had shared an email with me that her narc sent her! A true love letter!! Not!! He sent these nasty insulting emails to her regularly! Just complete projection!! As I read, I know I would have never put up with such garbage! NEVER! But the silent treatment what a way to sock it to me!! They are Evil Vampires, what ever compeletes the mission! Idealize, devalue,discard! It's been almost a year for me. Silence = Peace! Hunter
Aug 23 - 10AM
ordinarycourage
ordinarycourage's picture

Silent Treatment

We long for validation and connection with someone we love. That's a good thing, if the person we love is NOT a narc. Now I am grateful for the silent treatment!
Aug 24 - 1PM (Reply to #2)
badjer
badjer's picture

Wow too true. When 'love'

Wow too true. When 'love' has you crying chasing and feeling physically ill…it's time to move on….. Mine used silent treatment on me. If we had even a small falling out….I had to break the ice first. When we had a huge falling out, he didn't contact me for 2 days and I was left to contact him…..somehow it ended up being my fault….. I think one of the posters on here said that when they have used up all their goodwill and charm and know that they can't woo / charm / fool you any more, they go for good. I suspected this with my ex. When I told him after our 'reunion' that I had changed and that his silence had 'done damage', I think the penny really dropped for him - the golden days of my adoration were gone and in its place was cynicism and a hardness that wasn't there before. perhaps what he meant by "we've lost our spark". Either way, it didn't take him long to decide to bolt and bolt he did. It is only with time, tears and healing that I look back and see I had a very narrow escape. The silent treatment is evil and I was accustomed to it because my mother did it to me as a child, as did my father - and my ex was a carbon copy of him - so it was familiar. The more I have NC with him and he has NC with me, the more I look back and see that I was abused and brainwashed. Do I want that back now? Hell no! Peace to all XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX