Arguing Just to Argue

3 posts / 0 new
Last post
#1 Jul 23 - 11PM
Anonymous (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Arguing Just to Argue

by Kathy Krajco

I think that my long experience with narcissists has given me a sore spot. I really am bugged by any irrationality in others. It's easy to see why. Narcissists use irrationality as a debating tactic. It's wall of flak they throw up to block communication. A way of making sure you make no point. A way of making sure nothing gets through the wall of flak they throw up.

Been there. So I have no patience with unreasonableness in others. This is odd, because I am very patient with others in just about any other way you care to name. But the moment they are being unreasonable, look out. I REALLY don't like that.

I guess we all (wrongly) assume others are like ourselves. When I am discussing or debating an issue with someone, I really believe what I'm saying. If you make a point or raise a valid, cogent argument against my opinion, or cite facts contradictory to to it, I won't just deny them and throw up a wall of straw men and irrationality and other rhetorical devices in an exercise of verbal dodgeball. I will consider what you say. I am open to changing my mind.

It wouldn't embarrass me at all to do that - to say, "Well, I guess you're right. You changed my mind."

This isn't because I'm not a competitive person. On a tennis court you should see how competitive I can be! But everything has its place, and competitiveness does not belong in friendly personal relations. At least not to my way of thinking.

So, the moment I sense the hypocrisy of arguing just to argue (like a narcissist does, because he or she MUST win), I get ticked off.

I wonder if others feel the same. I wonder if sensitivity to this isn't a result of long experience with (deliberately) irrational narcissists who argue just to argue at the level of a three-year-old.

In my case I think it is. I came to hate that blathering fog horn of irrational flak so much that the moment I sense anyone arguing just to argue, I am done with them. I have zero patience for that. Narcissists used it all up.

http://narc-attack.blogspot.com

Jul 24 - 6PM
finallydone
finallydone's picture

Amen and God Bless her soul

This is sooooooo true. "Blathering fog horn of irrational flak." I could not have said that any better. The description she gives of how it feels and sounds is amazing!!
Dec 17 - 10PM (Reply to #2)
Barbara (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Arguing just to Argue

READ TOP POST ~~~~~~~~~ The truth will set you free... but first it will piss you off - Gloria Steinem Visit My Abuse Website