In addition to the 2 options, mine would do the silent treatment and not respond at all. That's always been his signature payback.
There's no excuse for these sickos.
I had broke NC so many times before when he would D&D me. I did this for 20 years. I knew this last D&D HAD to be the last one or I would never recover. You matter more and he will never change. You are doing good with your NC, keep going and you will feel great. Once you are NC because you want to be NC, its awesome! The only way you will get there is to maintain NC. Fight those urges. Keep going:)
Option 3,
I had broke NC so many times
I am almost 11wks out, But