Why I have a hard time surrendering to the co-dependency theory....

38 posts / 0 new
Last post
#1 Mar 23 - 3AM
Anonymous (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Why I have a hard time surrendering to the co-dependency theory....

Why I have a hard time letting y’all be “Co-dependent

Historically, the concept of codependence "comes directly out of Alcoholics Anonymous, part of a dawning realization that the problem was not solely the addict, but also the family and friends who constitute a network for the alcoholic."[2] It was subsequently broadened to cover the way "that the codependent person is fixated on another person for approval, sustenance, and so on."[2] As such, the concept overlaps with, but developed in the main independently from, the older psychoanalytic concept of the "'passive dependent personality' ... attaching himself to a stronger personality."[3]
Some would retain the stricter, narrower dictionary definition of codependency, which requires one person to be physically or psychologically addicted, such as to heroin, and the second person to be psychologically dependent on that behavior.
-Wikipedia

That being said, note clearly, not only did it come from AA BUT they theorized that “Part of the problem was NOT the addict but also the family and friends that constitute a network for the alcoholic” BLAME/PROJECTION…

THEN though spin…

”It was subsequently BROADENED (cause it would reach a wider audience – follow the money trail) AND the concept (conveniently) OVERLAPS with, but is “independent” (humph)…from an OLDER PSYCHOANALYTIC CONCEPT of “Passive Dependent”…
NO WAY!!!
(You mean they didn’t re-invent the wheel)?

Now, I ask you…do you feel you can be cured of your co-dependency? Really think about this…do you believe you can heal? If you answered yes I have very bad news…

SEE…the older concept…that “Passive Dependent” which really what the hell is the difference…
co-dependent/passive dependent, sounds like the same stuff to me…well…guess what…

Dependent personality disorder is one of several personality disorders listed in the newest edition of the standard reference guide: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, also known as the DSM-IV-TR.

AND…you will note, that for the most part, in 2013 there is a very good chance that some of the personality disorders will be streamlined under the umbrella of psychopath and that they are discussing this issue.

Nothing is set in stone – but if it were me…and yea, I’m not a professional…I’d be a little cautious putting myself in a box where some shrink will have an institution justifying A. Not treating me and B. Finding me incurable and C. Calling me not co-dependent or passive dependent but Psychopath...I don't think you'll be thinking it works for you then...

Just stay open, that’s all I’m saying if you’re going to read do it carefully.

I took a class in psychology in college. We had these cases we had to read. It was a psych class nothing major. Each week the professor would give a list of criteria before we knew what the illness was – he wanted to see how clearly we could analyze the information and later he would disclose the “mystery” illness…every week we were calling ourselves EVERYTHING because if you read into something enough you can make it fit.

Well, the last week low and behold, he gave us the last diagnostic criteria case…and wouldn’t you know it…approximately 85 percent of the class volunteered that they believed that they suffered from no other than Mental Retardation. That was an eye opener for me…and YES…I too raised my hand that day.

Mar 23 - 5AM
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

Hey Guys

I wont be commenting on these threads anymore they are becoming counter productive and distracting to others. There are people on here making posts that need to be addressed. For me I dont really come here for answers anymore just to debate or maybe help someone else. I found my answers and I am not healed but I fell liberated atleast for now. Stay tuned....
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #37)
ImStrong
ImStrong's picture

I am no follower..i am 100% a

I am no follower..i am 100% a leader but im going to follow you on this one..to many articles on this and,where not going anywhere..where getting to point of being warnined and thats never good

"In the fiery pit lays a man with two faces.One is the face of a God and the other a face of the Devil.Beware He lurks your souls.Keep one hand on your heart and the other hand over your eyes. Let him walk pass you not into you.Ghost of love will possess

Mar 23 - 5AM
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

Michelle

You "cautioned" me somewhere on here. Here's the deal. I am a 43 year old woman working in a completely male dominated industry. I earn a six figure income which doesnt really matter but I would digress and say corporate america doesnt pay for stupidity (well I mean not most of the time LOL). I can read a list of behaviors and know if it fits me. and if you want to go down that road we shouldnt be calling narcs narcs then.
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #32)
Steph
Steph's picture

if your "six figure" income

if your "six figure" income doesn't matter...why mention it? The intelligence on this board has never been questioned. Oh, and I have a degree and earn an annual 6 digit figure too ( as do probably many here) ....not that it matters, of course.
Mar 23 - 6AM (Reply to #34)
ImStrong
ImStrong's picture

Michelle and sick of it I am whoever lol

Michelle and sick of it I am a 27 yearold student looking to make six figures like you all..im looking to be down in other words I am in ny..all this six figure bragging is making me jealous lol I have a resume..hook a sis up

"In the fiery pit lays a man with two faces.One is the face of a God and the other a face of the Devil.Beware He lurks your souls.Keep one hand on your heart and the other hand over your eyes. Let him walk pass you not into you.Ghost of love will possess

Mar 23 - 6AM (Reply to #35)
Steph
Steph's picture

haha! That made me laugh. I

haha! That made me laugh. I don't think anyone is actually braggin though....even though it looks that way ( embarassed now:( ) I think we are all hard headed chicks and we are tryin to prove we are....smart? intelligent? worthy? I dunno. Money doesn't matter. Well off or not - somehow, we still ended up here, right?
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #33)
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

NO Response. It was explained

NO Response. It was explained in my post
Mar 23 - 5AM
jen79
jen79's picture

It doesnt matter how you call it

And everyone has to find an answer for themselves. I can speak only for myself. I know I have some core wounds, considering my childhood, it would be unhuman to not have that core wound. It is now that I am faced with it. I just know, I have a hard time finding a meaning for my life without being there that I can give my love too. I now have to learn to give it to myself. I defenetly have a problem with people who I cared for and who abandoned me. It doesnt mean I stay forver in such relationships, but it takes me long time to detach from it. Too long. I dont see this issue just within me. I think its a society condition as well. And we have to also see where human came from, from small groups where the survival dependent on the people around them. Its an survival instinct. It takes alot of consciousness to not feel pain if a loved one stops loving you. And it takes even more awareness to let them go and to not try to fix them, or tryinng to get that love back. I admire everyone who could clear themselves out from that need to be loved by others. I dont know if I will ever be free of that. I think its something very human, and to be honest I never met a person who didnt struggle with it. I met person who talked the talk, WHILE they were in a relationship, maybe not even a good one, but the feeling someone being around, that you are not totally alone can give you a feeling of security. And then it is easy to say to talk the be happy with yourself talk. Or they had at least kids or pets around them. I never met a person, who didnt had a problem with it, they were either still working on that issue, or they are narcs that cover themselves in the I can be alone thing, while having tons of supply around them. So again, it doesnt matter, which label you give it, show me a person that doesnt have a problem when you realize you dont have friends you can count on, your loved one doesnt love you, and your family doesnt love you either. Its the toughest lesson we can learn in this life, to overcome that.
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #29)
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

Jen

No one has pondered this stuff more than you my sister. However you feel about this is right for you. You certainly have given day and months of thought to this. You seem like you are getting a little better?
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #30)
jen79
jen79's picture

sick of it yes thanks I am better

But I fear its because I snooped my app and 8 messages were blocked last night. I couldnt read them, thank god. But I guess I got my fix just knowing. But I will try to take that "energy" for something productive today. Hugs
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #21)
Steph
Steph's picture

Jen79

I read this and I think....is this what our ultimate goal is.....to overcome and accept that we have NO ONE. No friends, no family. Nothing? I'm sorry, but that isn't compatible with life. We are human and it is human nature to have the need to feel love, to be touched etc. Obviously, we have to be selective with whom we allow in our lives, and we have to be happy with who we are first.....but....we are not meant to be completely alone....and that is NOT a psychological condition. It's human nature.
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #27)
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

now jen is wrong about her

now jen is wrong about her reality too? I dont even think Jen said she was codependent.
Mar 23 - 6AM (Reply to #28)
Steph
Steph's picture

and, I never called her

and, I never called her codependent....and I'm wrong to say wanting love is human nature? wow. grow the fuck up. this is getting so unbelievably out of hand.
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #22)
jen79
jen79's picture

staying strong

Is that my goal. Its not my goal to overcome this, but I see I have to find a way to NOT suffer about his any longer. I dont know what this is, but with awakening comes alot of pain, you suddenly see that the whole world is insane. And its not easy to go back to that and pretend you are happy with it. I realized that in my life, where is the love here, there is so much abuse and control and dysfunction around me, that I want to vomite. And before I start searching for like crazy for something different, something that proofs I am wrong, I will have to find a way to overcome that need to get security from others around me. I learned that lesson hard, you cannot count on anyone but yourself. It is a human condition indeed, but there has to be another way of living.
Mar 23 - 6AM (Reply to #23)
michele115 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Jen

I think that and I was reading about this today...about the human condition and the basic essential need for love...studies shown babies DIE from failure to thrive from lack of affction and nurturing...THEY DIE! I think that life is cyclical...love does not necessarily have to come from an intimate partner...it can come from friends, family etc... but sometimes in life we are isolated... From a "spritual" perspective it is believed that it is those times...that the universe somehow brings about circumstances, to pull you closer to the spritual....those times of isolation are times of spritual growth...the thought is that somehow the universe brings about instances in life of forced isolation to draw you closer to matters spritual AND again...that word "cyclical" and how funny the earth is a sphere...maybe the answer is in a circle! But during those times *more than others* I've heard that it is when we are drawn more to matters spritual and that kinda lessens the lonliness because we take on a new awareness?
Mar 23 - 6AM (Reply to #24)
jen79
jen79's picture

Michelle, its called the dark night of the soul

it will clear you out from all human conditions, and to be honest, would I have started to become spiritual, if there would have been one single thing left for me that I could hold on to? No. If everything falls apart, I mean really everything, and you start to wake up, then it will pain the hell out of you. And you have no other choice then finding some peace within you, not outside of you anymore. I cant hold onto anything anymore, love, friends, family, money, carrier, my health...it went all down the hill. And the more I surrender to it, the more free I become. Its the holding onto that causes the suffering. I cannot tell you, hey I am a great woman, with a big house, I earn my own money, drive my own car, I also look great, so why doesnt he want me, and then someone would comment, yeeah because he so afraid of you, you strong independent women, what looser he is. This doesnt work for me anymore, cause non of these things exist anymore, mentioned above. So what to do, when you suddenly find yourself in the looser category of society. Commiting suicide? So I think it is indeed human, and it also pushes you to some other level. No way to hide myself anymore behind "stuff".
Mar 23 - 1PM (Reply to #26)
michele115 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Jen

I cant hold onto anything anymore, love, friends, family, money, carrier, my health...it went all down the hill. And the more I surrender to it, the more free I become. Its the holding onto that causes the suffering. I read also *through theosophy* this concept of how the higher power/being/ universe/God is love and that he is in each of our souls...that it is the greatest force of love we can't even begin to imagine much less master on this plane. AND that essentially, we too have this power but it is through experiences - pain included that we learn most how to get closer to that by fighting the "human" emotions and striving closer to that "ultimate" love mastery which is unselfish and is not connected to another but ourselves as in our soul and this is how we connect to that greater power... And what you just said kinda triggered that memory because this feeling you are having sounds like the kind of experience they are talking about...the forced isolation...the conditions existing that in a way you have no control over and you are stuck in this feeling of isolation and the struggle to fight it and find your way out...kinda like a drawing or a trying of this "force" to pull you more towards it? And yes, we are all interconnected but then there is also this premise of release...releasing on a spritual level of other "souls" who have other journeys...and you have your soul journey to complete...the "letting go" of other souls so that you can master or move up a peg on your journey? Is that making any kind of sense?
Mar 23 - 6AM (Reply to #25)
michele115 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Jen

I've had many dark nights and as a matter of fact, seriously considered suicide when I lost my health in 2003. It wasn't due to any reason other than I was an inch away from being homeless, I lost my job, I had fibro and chronic fatigue and yes, the pain was worse than cancer...they describe CFS patients as being sicker than AIDS patients except for the last two months of life...you can google that...so I know darkness, I know lean times, I know pain...I live with physical pain daily...and I have learned to be happy without all the material trappings. NO suicide isn't an option. I considered it only as a means to ensure my son was no longer neglected as like you friends and family turned their backs on me did not believe me, this was before Big Pharma thought we were worth something...AND so if I were dead, the survivors benefits would come for my son and the "money" would entice some family member to care for him. He would not be in a shelter and he would eat every day...that is why I started thinking about it...not because of sadness...THAT and I could not imagine living with pain of that magnitude that even the highest dose possible of oxycontin DID not touch...I could not physically function, slept 16 hours a day, docs said there was nothing they could do, it was all in my head...I had no hope and could not imagine living the rest of my life like that. I am intrigued and will look into this more...the "dark night of the soul..." Thank you.
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #20)
michele115 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Jen...

I admire everyone who could clear themselves out from that need to be loved by others. I dont know if I will ever be free of that. I think its something very human, and to be honest I never met a person who didnt struggle with it. What you mentioned...is agreeed by most to be at the CORE of the human condition...a basic HUMAN need AND not worthy of any shame, and that is not my opinion, but the opinion of ancient philosphers, the Bible and Modern Psychology... To want and need be loved and accepted...it's not abnormal.
Mar 23 - 5AM
ImStrong
ImStrong's picture

We didnt say cure..but we can

We didnt say cure..but we can better..no matter what research says different..with the mans help up upstairs anythings possible..you just might be cured

"In the fiery pit lays a man with two faces.One is the face of a God and the other a face of the Devil.Beware He lurks your souls.Keep one hand on your heart and the other hand over your eyes. Let him walk pass you not into you.Ghost of love will possess

Mar 23 - 5AM
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

Here is a good article...

What is Codependency / Codependence ? This dance of Codependence is a dance of dysfunctional relationships - of relationships that do not work to meet our needs. That does not mean just romantic relationships, or family relationships, or even human relationships in general. The fact that dysfunction exists in our romantic, family, and human relationships is a symptom of the dysfunction that exists in our relationship with life, with being human. It is a symptom of the dysfunction which exists in our relationships with ourselves as human beings. And the dysfunction that exists in our relationship with ourselves is a symptom of Spiritual dis-ease, of not being in balance and harmony with the universe, of feeling disconnected from our Spiritual source. Codependence: The Dance of Wounded Souls by Robert Burney There are a variety of ways to describe the condition of codependency. Here are a few: Codependency is: At it's core, a dysfunctional relationship with self. We do not know how to Love our self in healthy ways because our parents did not know how to Love themselves. We were raised in shame-based societies that taught us that there is something wrong with being human. The messages we got often included that there is something wrong: with making mistakes; with not being perfect; with being sexual; with being emotional; with being too fat or too thin or too tall or too short or too whatever. As children we were taught to determine our worth in comparison with others. If we were smarter than, prettier than, better grades than, faster than, etc. - then we were validated and got the message that we had worth. In a codependent society everyone has to have someone to look down on in order to feel good about themselves. And, conversely, there is always someone we can compare ourselves to that can cause us to not feel good enough. Codependency could: More accurately be called outer or external dependence. The condition of codependence is about giving power over our self esteem to outside sources/agencies or external manifestations. We were taught to look outside of our selves to people, places, and things - to money, property and prestige, to determine if we have worth. That causes us to put false gods before us. We make money or achievement or popularity or material possessions or the "right" marriage the Higher Power that determines if we have worth. We take our self-definition and self-worth from external manifestations of our own being so that looks or talent or intelligence becomes the Higher Power that we look to in determining if we have worth. All outside and external conditions are temporary and could change in a moment. If we make a temporary condition our Higher Power we are setting ourselves up to be a victim - and, in blind devotion to that Higher Power we are pursuing, we often victimize other people on our way to proving we have worth. (I believe that we are all ONE. That we all have equal worth as Spiritual Beings, as sons and daughters of the God-Force / Goddess Energy / Great Spirit - not because of any external manifestation or outside condition.) Codependency is: A particularly vicious form of delayed stress syndrome. Instead of being traumatized in a foreign country against an identified enemy during a war, as soldiers who have delayed stress are - we were traumatized in our sanctuaries by the people we loved the most. Instead of having experienced that trauma for a year or two as a soldier might - we experienced it on a daily basis for 16 or 17 or 18 years. A soldier has to shut down emotionally in order to survive in a war zone. We had to shut down emotionally because we were surrounded by adults who were emotional cripples of one sort or another. Codependency is: A dysfunctional emotional and behavioral defense system. When a society is emotionally dishonest, the people of that society are set up to be emotionally dysfunctional. In this society being emotional is described as falling apart, losing it, going to pieces, coming unglued, etc. (Other cultures give more permission to be emotional but then the emotions are usually expressed in ways that are out of balance to the extreme of letting the emotions control. The goal is balance between emotional and mental - between the intuitive and the rational.) Traditionally in this society men have been taught that anger is the only acceptable emotion for a man to express, while women are taught that it is not acceptable for them to be angry. If it is not ok to own all of our emotions then we can not know who we are as emotional beings. [Also traditionally, women are taught to be codependent - take their self-definition (including their names) and self-worth - from their relationships with men, while men are taught to be codependent on their work/career/ability to produce, and from their presumed superiority to women.] Codependency is: A disease of lost self. If we are not validated and affirmed for who we are in childhood then we don't believe we are worthy or lovable. Often we got validated and affirmed by one parent and put down by the other. When the parent who is "loving" does not protect us - or themselves - from the parent that is abusive, it is a betrayal that sets us up to have low self esteem because the affirmation we received was invalidated right in our own homes. And being affirmed for being who we are is very different than being affirmed for who our parents wanted us to be - if they could not see themselves clearly then they sure could not see us clearly. In order to survive, children adapt whatever behavior will work best in helping them get their survival needs met. We then grow up to be adults who don't know our self and keep dancing the dance we learned as children. A dysfunctional relationship is one that does not work to make us happy. Codependency is about having a dysfunctional relationship with self. With our own bodies, minds, emotions, and spirits. With our own gender and sexuality. With being human. Because we have dysfunctional relationships internally we have dysfunctional relationships externally. We try to fill the hole we feel inside of our self with something or someone outside of us - it does not work.
Mar 23 - 6AM (Reply to #17)
michele115 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

I'm not talking about an article

AGAIN, you are going by the watered down version...if you are going to say you are something then you go balls to the wall with it. You go by the checklist that Co-dependent's annonymous puts out which I posted. If you feel you meet that criteria fine. Otherwise, you are professing to be something that is a watered down version from someone that isn't even following the damn guidelines! This is where I have the problem, I could identify with some of this guys stuff but you know what...it's a campaign of brainwashing on his part to sell books he's selling you the concept *at least in this article* that you are co-dependent...AND his stuff barely touches the CRITERIA...the OFFICIAL CRITERIA and that may be where you and I are locking horns...then there will be this whole other band of folks who read this article and say Oh yea, I'm co dependent too and it's MIS information... That is an issue. I will post again the official criteria and if you feel you are all those things, you may go in "co-dependent" peace. But I am doing my best not to mislead any member on this board but allow them to make well informed decisions for themselves which is why I will post the criteria, which I'm not sure if Miss Shreiber has done that.
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #12)
michele115 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Sickofit

Due to copywright liability when we post, we are required to cite the title/author and/or website in other words as much information so that there is not a problem legally on copywright issues. Additionally, we need to check for disclaimers generally you can copy an article and they won't bite your head off as long as you have the author and title... Could you please add that information to the aforementioned article? it is not a personal challenge but the attempt to prevent any legal complications for Miss Scott. thanks.
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #15)
ImStrong
ImStrong's picture

Michelle whats your views on

Michelle whats your views on sick of it article that she posted..how do you feel about it..

"In the fiery pit lays a man with two faces.One is the face of a God and the other a face of the Devil.Beware He lurks your souls.Keep one hand on your heart and the other hand over your eyes. Let him walk pass you not into you.Ghost of love will possess

Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #16)
michele115 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

I'm strong

I think you know the answer to that...that isn't a mystery, but how do YOU feel about it - that is more important...I'm further along in the process.
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #13)
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

its already in there

its already in there Codependence: The Dance of Wounded Souls by Robert Burney
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #14)
michele115 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Sickofit

There are copywright infringement laws that Miss Scott can be financially liable for if it is not clear. I note in the paragraph that it's mentioned, but unless I'm blind...which I might be... It should be something like...I belive it's an excerpt no? Exerpt from: Dance of the Wounded Souls by:... or Robert Burney/Dance of the Wounded Souls... This again is a legal issue not my personal request...don't kill the messenger. You may recall this came up before when we had a different group on board...I forgot the offense but we have been asked to pay close attention. The fines can get pretty steep...and that would affect the sustanability of the board.
Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #11)
ImStrong
ImStrong's picture

This article again proves

This article again proves what I was saying..dealing and focusing on you not him..facing your own innerself demons and moving on as a individual most importantly a better individial than you was before

"In the fiery pit lays a man with two faces.One is the face of a God and the other a face of the Devil.Beware He lurks your souls.Keep one hand on your heart and the other hand over your eyes. Let him walk pass you not into you.Ghost of love will possess

Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #10)
ImStrong
ImStrong's picture

Mind blowing I amazed this is

Mind blowing I amazed this is a good article..and nothing in this article "Blaims the victim..(aplauds)

"In the fiery pit lays a man with two faces.One is the face of a God and the other a face of the Devil.Beware He lurks your souls.Keep one hand on your heart and the other hand over your eyes. Let him walk pass you not into you.Ghost of love will possess

Mar 23 - 5AM (Reply to #9)
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

If we were smarter than,

If we were smarter than, prettier than, better grades than, faster than, etc. - then we were validated and got the message that we had worth. That statement is me to a tee.